An Unexpected and Enjoyable Turn of the Lesbian Best Friend TropeAs some of my supporters over on Patreon will know, I recently put out a deep dive into the character Yaya from Strawberry Panic. In it, I discussed her role in the series as fulfilling the lesbian best friend trope. This archetype, a character who surfers for loving the protagonist, comes in various forms and is a staple of current Yuri and Yuri adjacent media. However, I thought it might be worth examining a work that entirely revolves around the lesbian best friend, Ana C. Sánchez’s Alter Ego. This Spanish manga was recently released by Tokyopop earlier this year under their Love X Love and international women of manga line. I was eager to see what Sánchez did with the classic Yuri concepts in this energetic one-shot.I mentioned that the best friend is usually a supporting character interacting with the protagonist, but in the case of Alter Ego, she is the main character. University student Noel is in love with her best friend and classmate Elena. However, she has never been able to voice that love before. She has always contented herself with being close to Elena. However, now that Elena has a new boyfriend, Noel’s chances to be intimate with her friend are dwindling. When Elena’s other best friend, a writer named June, moves to town and begins living next to Noel, it is too much for the girl to bear.The basic premise of this series is well established and easy to grasp. The story focuses less on Noel reconciling her feelings for Elena, as other unrequited love Yuri stories have in the past. Instead, the manga follows her struggle to deal with the changing reality of her friendship with Elena. While the two used to be solitary companions, the addition of Elena’s boyfriend and June clearly has Noel feeling insecure and fearful. These feelings manifest in some truly toxic behavior, including shouting at her friend and generally acting selfishly. Noel’s behavior makes it challenging to enjoy and root for her. However, to Alter Ego’s credits, the actions are always treated as inappropriate and not played for cuteness or laughs. Much of Noel’s struggles involve her guilt over her treatment of Elena. Unfortunately, although she makes some steps to make reparations, the single-volume work is too short to accommodate a complete personality swap, so Alter Ego is trapped between a rock and a hard place or making a likable character and keeping proper pacing.Speaking of the story’s pacing, it is relatively strong. Particularly in the first half of the story, the plot slowly moves forward as the stakes for Noel are established and escalated. As June enters the story, she appropriately disrupts the rhythm Sánchez set up while still keeping the progress constant. Through the chapters, we slowly begin to learn more about this young writer, and the focus of the story smoothly transitions from Noel and Elena to Noel and June. Alter Ego does a great job at helping readers discover elements of June’s personality and history alongside Noel, thanks to the latter’s perception and naturally building a relationship with June.Here is where we get to the central Yuri element of the story, June and Noel’s relationship. For (minor spoilers ahead), it turns out that both girls love Elena. This shared affection and their different perspectives of it drive the girls together. While Noel predominantly acts selfishly and controlling, June is the type of lesbian best friend that just wants to see the other happy, to sacrifice her own desire to know the one she loves is content. June imparts these principles onto Noel to mixed results, as discussed earlier, but the direction the work aims is clear, and the logic follows for both girls.June and Noel’s mutual love for Elena, the person who brought them together in the first place, becomes the foundation for their relationship. It is a rather fun twist on the lesbian best friend trope as the two girls begin hanging out together and share their interests outside of Elena. As one would expect, there is a fair bit of angst, a confession, and at the end, they are together. Unfortunately, while the premise that got them there is a fun manipulation of the lesbian best friend trope, the romance’s path is predictable with the rushed resolution you would expect of a one-shot. However, the execution is pretty smooth, and except for Noel, particularly at the start of the story, its characters are likable enough to carry to drama and romance.Sánchez’s artwork is above average. I particularly enjoyed her attention to the character’s outfits and designs. The settings are unremarkable but do not distract from the work’s overall quality, and the background characters add a lot to make the world of Alter Ego full. The more emotional scenes are illustrated well, with Noel’s pain and frustration being especially apparent. However, there are a few flaws and inconsistencies. Occasionally, especially in comedic moments, the art drifts a little closer to the moe edge and dips noticeably in quality. The character designs overall, while I enjoyed them, look a little younger than I would have expected. I honestly thought they were high school students until the work explicitly states that June is 24. Alter Ego already feels like an angsty high school Yuri romance despite its characters, and the art did little to help that feeling.Alter Ego is an enjoyable single-volume Yuri drama. Sánchez did an admirable job creating a compelling story and characters, and her play on unrequited love is exciting and enthralling. While it does little new, Alter Ego is a highly polished manga with flawed characters, interesting relationships, and superb storytelling. There are also some fantastic art inserts at the start of the manga and a few vibrant color pages that stuck in my mind longer than most similar volumes have. I recommend Alter Ego for a solid afternoon Summer read and am eager to continue following its creator to see what else she does. Thank you, Tokyopop, for bringing this international manga to English audiences.Special thanks to translation Nanette McGuinness, Editor Lena Atanassova, and the rest of the team at Tokyopop for their excellent work on Alter Ego.Ratings:Story – 7Characters – 6Art – 7LGBTQ – 6Sexual Content – 2Final – 6Check out Alter Ego in English digitally and in print today: https://amzn.to/3jFruf1Reading official releases helps support creators and publishers. YuriMother makes a small commission from sales to help fund future content.
Jun 29, 2021 • Subscribe
More like this
Alter Ego Review
Alter Ego is a yuri romance, by Ana C. Sánchez, that’s been released by Tokyopop, as a part of their International Women of Manga line. Dealing with themes…
‘Alter Ego’ Early Review Access
Noel’s world is shattering. First the woman she loves, Elena, gets a boyfriend and now Elena’s other best friend is moving to town! It is almost too much…
Alter Ego by Ana C. Sánchez
Noel is in love with her best friend, Elena. Or is she? She’s jealous when Elena spends time withe her boyfriend and now she’s going to have a…
D4DJ All Mix – Episode 4 – RONDO’S Alter Ego Dilemma
Episode impressions of D4DJ All Mix -Episode 4 as Lyrical Lily performed, Tsubaki noticed something was up with Aoi. Yep, it has to do with the nightclub Alter…
International Yuri Manga ‘Alter Ego’ Released in EnglishToday, Tokyopop released Yuri...
International Yuri Manga ‘Alter Ego’ Released in EnglishToday, Tokyopop released Yuri manga Alter Ego in print. The manga was previously released digitally in English in December 2020.Alter Ego…
What’s your current favorite LGBTQ+ manga?
Favorite completed title? Favorite ongoing series? Something you want to see licensed/rescued?
Ego Lied! – Blue Lock Ep 11 Review
Ego reveals that he lied about there being more players in other buildings at the facility. Team Z walks into the second selection challenge with confidence.
LGBTQ Manga Review – If I Could Reach You Vol. 4 & 5
If I Could Reach You remains an incredibly emotional and powerful storyI vaguely remember once staying home from school as a child for a somewhat extended period with an illness, and…
What LGBTQ+ anime or manga gives you joy?
What title gets you through hard times? What feels like a hopeful, nuanced real-world story? What’s your go-to escapist story?
BlazBlue: Alter Memory Review: Time Rewinds and Jumbled Perspectives
Another series I kept up with during the fall 2013 season is BlazBlue: Alter Memory. While there were a great many I enjoyed keeping up with, I honestly…
![Featured image for Lupisregina Beta, 1/8 Scale, Overlord (Alter) [Figure Review]](https://cdn.aniblogtracker.com/live/20231212/1702379770.74676.111377.jpg)
Lupisregina Beta, 1/8 Scale, Overlord (Alter) [Figure Review]
Alter + So-bin design equals peak anime figure! Manufacturer Picture Actual Figure Review Luspisregina Beta Alter info Otaku Sinh’s collection I bought it here! Price ¥19,600 (Figure)+ ¥5,269…
Farewell to My Alter GN
Farewell to My Alter proves that Nio Nakatani is not a creator to pigeonhole.
Birdie Wing Episode 10: Ego Putt
Eve had trouble getting used to her new residence and needed some help.
Manga de Wakaru LGBQ+ (マンガでわかるLGBTQ+）
I follow a number of Japanese sexual and gender minority groups on Twitter. I’ve even created a Twitter list with all the JP groups I follow, knowing that…
LGBTQ Manga: Our Dreams at Dusk Shimanami Tasogare, Volume 4 (English)
I have been waiting for this day for more than a year and I’m so very excited that at last I will have people with whom I can…
What LGBTQ+ manga would you like to see get an anime?
Series or film? Choice of studio or staff? Is there a title that would work better as a live drama
Alter Egos in VTubing and Pro Wrestling
Sometimes, I think about how so many members of hololive have “other personas,” and I don’t mean past lives as other streamers or entertainers. More than simply being…
LGBTQ Manga Review — I’m in Love with the Villainess Vol. 1 (Manga)A New Look on a Compelling...
LGBTQ Manga Review — I’m in Love with the Villainess Vol. 1 (Manga)A New Look on a Compelling and Innovative SeriesA manga adaptation of one of the best…
Yuri and LGBTQ+ Manga, Anime, and Games to Enjoy this Pride Month
Manga and Comics I’m in Love with the Villainess Ordinary office worker Oohashi Rei wakes up in the body of the protagonist of her favorite otome game, Revolution. To her…
Girl Meets Girl, veil, Wandering Son, Bloom Into You, Girl Meets Girl
My Top 9 LGBTQ+ Manga You Should Check Out This Pride Month!
If you were looking for manga with a positive LGBTQ+ message behind it or even representation over a decade ago it would have been near impossible to find,…
LGBTQ+ Events in Tokyo for 2024
Here are some creative ways to get out and be yourself, from everyday activities to annual celebrations enjoy these LGBTQ+ events in Tokyo.
What Blue Lock teaches you about ego | An Analysis
In this video, I'm going to analyse Blue Lock and why this show is so much connected towards ego. The Squid Game acapella you heard in the video:…
New Lesbian Manga ‘Even Though We’re Adults’ from Acclaimed LGBTQ Creator Released in English
The first volume of Yuri manga series Even Though We’re Adults (Otona ni Natte mo) was released Tuesday in English by Seven Seas Entertainment. This is the latest…
Should First 4 Figures Alter Dark Magician Girl’s Eyes?
First 4 Figures wants to know: Should it change the appearance of its Dark Magician Girl PVC figure’s eyes? On Monday evening, company CEO Alex Davis reached out…
Farewell to My Alter, Nio Nakatani Short Story Collection
Farewell to My Alter, Nio Nakatani Short Story Collection, from Yen Press works equally well as a Yuri collection, a science fiction/fantasy collection, or a collection of Nakatani-sensei’s…
LGBTQ Light Novel Review – I'm in Love with the Villainess Vol. 2
A Defining and Relentlessly Queer Work in the Next Era of Yuri I have backed myself into a corner and see no way out of it. For I have already awarded…
Group Psychology & An Analysis of Ego #1: Tradition & Class Consciousness
Disclaimer: This post has been brought to you thanks to the generosity of JNES After Dusk, all praise goes to them, all fault lies with me. This will…
Japan PM’s Secretary Retracts Anti-LGBTQ+ Comments
Just days after his boss threw cold water on marriage equality, Prime Minister Kishida Fumio's secretary makes blatantly anti-LGBTQ+ comments.
Covering the LGBTQ+ Spectrum in Incompatible Species
When a project boasts the inclusion of LGBTQ+ characters, I more often than not find myself disappointed. Most of the time the visual novel in question only feature…
Manga Adaptation of Hit LGBTQ Series ‘I’m in Love with the Villainess’ Licensed in English
On Tuesday, Seven Seas Entertainment announced that it had licensed Aonoshimo’s manga adaptation of Inori’s hit Yuri isekai series I’m in Love with the Villainess. The first volume…
#97 - Pride Month Special! LGBTQ+ Indentity in Anime, Manga, and Fandom feat. Meta and RetroSofa
Sully and Tori are joined by two amazing guests to have a candid discussion about LGBTQ+ representation in anime, manga, and fandom spaces. Meta you know as the editor…
Don’t @ Me: Seven of my Anime Opinions: Arjuna Alter Edition
It’s Monday, which means it is time again for this. Welcome back to Don’t @ Me. The place where, like any good hentai tier list. I rank and…
Anime World Order Show # 214 – Ego Hat, You’ve Ruined My Life
It’s our annual Thanksgiving trivia episode! We’re joined this time by the highly versatile writer Kara Dennison (@RubyCosmos), who in addition to writing prose fiction also contributes…
The Ultimate Test of Ego! Blue Lock's Race to the Top
The Ultimate Test of Ego! Blue Lock's Race to the Top With no shortage of action, rivalry, betrayal, and tons of intensity, it's a given that Blue Lock has…
LGBTQ Manga: Stop!! Hibarikun! Complete Edition, Volume 1 (ストップ!!ひばりくん! コンプリート・エディション)
Some series are famous because they create a whole new chapter of fandom. Others spearhead a new style of art or story telling. But there are some series…
Weekly Round-Up, 6-12 December 2023: Anime Worker Depression, LGBTQ+ Gains, and Shoujosei Manga Awards
AniFem Round-Up Transmasculinity and queer sexuality in the works of Ikeda Riyoko While her works are nearing 50 years old, Ikeda’s characters still resonate as explorations of gender…
Weekly Round-Up, 6-12 December 2023: Anime Worker Depression, LGBTQ+ Gains, and Shoujosei Manga Awards
AniFem Round-Up Transmasculinity and queer sexuality in the works of Ikeda Riyoko While her works are nearing 50 years old, Ikeda’s characters still resonate as explorations of gender…
![Featured image for Milim Nava, 1/7 Scale, That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime (Alter) [Figure Review]](https://cdn.aniblogtracker.com/live/20221120/1668912010.47088.78323.jpg)
Milim Nava, 1/7 Scale, That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime (Alter) [Figure Review]
For an accurate and clean looking scale figure of Milim Nava off of Tensura, this Alter version has a strong case for being the best one out there.…
Top 6 LGBTQ Korean Drama Of All Time
Top 6 LGBTQ Korean drama of all time There is no guessing that Asian countries, including South Korea, Singapore, Japan are conservative countries. LGBTQ re
Thoughts on Farewell to My Alter: Nio Nakatani Short Story Collection
Farewell to My Alter: Nio Nakatani Short Story Collection is exactly what it says in the title: a collection of short stories written and illustrated by Nio Nakatani.…
Ask John: Should Creators Be Allowed to Alter Their Prior Works?
Question: Do you believe when an anime creator or mangaka releases a work to the public that it’s final? Should an artist be able to go back and…
Yuri Expert Erica Friedman Dives Into LGBTQ Anime & Manga History in New Book ‘By Your...
Yuri Expert Erica Friedman Dives Into LGBTQ Anime & Manga History in New Book ‘By Your Side’ – June 2022In February, Yuri researcher and trend-setter Erica Friedman announced…
Bringing His Ego to the Role: BLUE LOCK Voice Actor Kazuki Ura
Ura explains, “As a voice actor, I have the ego that I don't want to lose to anybody. I want to be the best at everything, especially when…
Manga Review – F
F エフ ROKUDA Noboru Seinen – Comedy, drama, mature, sports, tragedy 20 Volumes of 28 Volumes (complete) Media Do (MediBang) Summary: Gunma likes to play around with girls,…
Manga Review – Tangled
Tangled Disney塔の上のラプンツェル (Disney Tou no Ue no Rapunzel) KANAKI Shiori Shoujo – Fantasy, romance 1 Volume (complete) TOKYOPOP Summary: Rapunzel loves the strange stars she sees every year…
Manga Review – Ayanashi
Ayanashi アヤナシ KAJIMOTO Yukihiro Shounen – Action, adventure, fantasy 1 Volume of 4 Volumes (complete) Kodansha Comics Summary: Gruesome monsters known as ogres roam the lands, forcing humans…
Blame! (Manga) Review
Blame! is a sci-fi action series about Killy's search for a human with the Net Terminal Gene within the Megastructure.
Mujirushi – Manga Review
Guys, I really liked Mujirushi. I'm so glad I randomly bought it because this is one manga I'm pretty sure I'm going to reread through the years.
NightS Manga Review
Yakuza, mechanics, and others fall in love… oh, and some high school kids, but who cares about them?
![Featured image for Happiness [Manga Review]](https://cdn.aniblogtracker.com/live/20210808/1628413395.18953.44553.jpg)
Happiness [Manga Review]
Happiness [Manga Review] Happiness is another story from the author of Aku No Hana. Going into Happiness I was eager to see how Shuuzou Oshimi will work with Horror as an…
