At the beginning of 2023, I vowed to post one review or essay per month, a goal I met for the first half of the year. Then work got busy, and my husband and I started doing home improvement projects we’d been putting off, making it harder to find the bandwidth for reviewing. The reviews I did publish, however, seemed to have found an audience, so I’m setting the same goal for myself in 2024, with the aim of writing more in-depth essays about older titles like Furari and BL Metamorphosis, as well as more reviews of classic, indie, and overlooked manga. My other major goal for 2024 is to revive The Manga Review, though the upheaval on Twitter has made me wonder whether I’d reach more people with a newsletter than... The post The Manga Critic’s Year in Review: 2023 first appeared on Manga Bookshelf.
Dec 31, 2023 • Subscribe
More like this
2023 Year in Review
Books Book that made me nod my head again and again and also left me deeply unsettled: Naomi Klein’s Doppelganger Best book about scary caves: The Luminous Dead…
Year in Review 2023
A new year, a new reflection on the past year’s events. These posts have become somewhat therapeutic over the past few years, helping me look back at the…
2023 Gunpla Year In Review
This guide marks a major milestone for Gunpla 101: our TENTH year-in-review post in a row! Gunpla 101 has been around for an entire decade! John and I…
2019 Manga Year in Review
[ Last post: 2019 Manga Mid-Year in Review! ] [ Standard disclaimer: Spoilers! Lots of spoilers! ] Ranking is looser here than it is with my anime lists.…
JoJo’s Bizarre Encyclopedia: 2023 Year in Review
The 2023 Year in Review for JoJo's Bizarre Encyclopedia showcases the wiki and news site's top pages, searches, and demographics with colorful graphics.
2023 Anime Year in Review: Honorable Mention
It's Top 10 time again already!? Indeed it is, and quite a challenge that's going to be for this year, too.
2023 in Review: The Best and Strangest of the Year
As we say good-bye to 2023, it’s time to take a look at the highlights of the year as a whole, rather than just individual seasons. And my,…
10 Manga in the year 2010
I remember when I first started reading manga. There weren’t a lot of series out and Viz was still printing their manga in giant books. In would be…
Top Anime of 2023 (And Year in Review)
Another year has come and gone, leaving us undeniably older and presumably wiser, though at this point it’s hard for me to tell if each new year of…
BanG Dream!, BanG Dream! It's MyGO!!!!!, Dear Brother, Mobile Suit Gundam, One Piece
Yata’s 2023 Anime Year in Review & Top 10
Yata here. You know what time it is! Another year of anime in the books, another massive recap article to compensate for how little we here at For…
The Manga Review: Year-End Spectacular
As 2022 draws to a close, there’s still time to support your favorite manga charity with a book or cash donation. Two organizations I highly recommend are Reader…
Critic’s Report: Amatsuki
This anime is awarded: Passed during a mysterious parallel thought of Edo period, Amatsuki is a very interesting anime that explores the relationship between the basic religious classes…
2023 Anime Year in Review Part II: #11-20
Unmistakably this past year was a very good one in anime (especially romance), with strength both in quantity and quality.
The Backlog: Another Year in Review
This one's about last year.
Year in Review: 2018
With 2018 behind us, let’s take a look back at some of the best things it had to offer.
Year in Review 2022
Can you believe this will be the fifth time I get to write this post? Technically the blog is just over 6 years old at this point, but…
Year In Review: 2020
With 2020 finally in the rear-view mirror, let’s take a look at some of the highlights in the world of anime, manga and video games. I really slacked…
Year in Review: 2019
Can you believe another year has passed already? With 2019 behind us, let’s take a look back at some of the best things it had to offer.
Year in review 2021
As I sit at my desk typing up this long overdue post, I’m reflecting on all that has changed over these last 6 months. Normally this post would…
The Anime Nostalgia Podcast - ep 126: 2023 Year in Review with GrantTheThief
Subscribers! Be sure to go to the blog to read the description easier & check out links for this episode! This episode is sponsored in p...
Critic’s Report: Amaenaide yo!
This anime is awarded: Amaenaideyo is your run of the mill harem anime, with one catch… The harem consists of nuns/monks and one very perverted guy. Don’t go…
Critic’s Report: AM Driver
This anime is awarded: This show is just painful to watch. Every single character is a poor cardboard cut-out of a tired stereo-type. There is absolutely no plot…
Critic’s Report: Aquarian Age
This anime is awarded: Personally, I found Aquarian Age to be extremely boring and confusing, although the ‘boring’ part can be accredited almost entirely to the ‘confusing’…
Critic’s Report: Angel Heart
This anime is awarded: Note* This series is a spin-off from another show called City Hunter, and uses many of it’s characters. All I did before watching this…
Critic’s Report: Angelic Layer
This anime is awarded: Like most tournament shows, the themes of doing your best and friendship pervade the experience. A doll used in the Angelic Fights is usually…
New Year, Same Me: 2023 Manga Run-down
Regrettably, my manga consumption in 2023 fell short of initial expectations (and if you think this is bad, wait until you see how few anime series I consumed,).…
Anime of the Year 2023
These are the looks you get if you haven’t watched Migi and Dali yet. Around November I found myself wondering if this year was truly one of the…
Anime of the Year 2023
These are the looks you get if you haven’t watched Migi and Dali yet. Around November I found myself wondering if this year was truly one of the…
Yamato Year 2023
If for some reason you were trying to avoid hearing about the classic Yamato saga in 2023, your work got harder as the 49th anniversary approached. The passing…
January 2023 Manga Review
Brought to you by an infinite supply of Pon de Ringu.
Ty’s Year in Review (2019)
2019 was another awesome year for the anime fandom. Sure, it saw its fair share of controversies – while everybody else was getting all worked up over Fire…
OTAKU YEAR IN REVIEW 2021
I cast an eye back over what I watched and read in 2021 (New and old).
Stínolez’s Year-in-review (2021)
It’s the beginning of a new year, and like everybody else I’m looking behind and wondering how I was able to survive 2021. We were all…
2016 Anime Year in Review
Anime 2015 was a fairly decent year, but it came off the heels of a garbage year for anime. 2016 seems so much better now. I’d say 2016…
Ace Attorney, Hundred, Phoenix, Sailor Moon Crystal, Flying Witch
2019 Anime Year in Review
Previous: 2018 Anime Year in Review 2019 Winter in Review – Final Thoughts 2019 Spring in Review – Final Thoughts 2019 Summer in Review – Final Thoughts […
2018 Anime Year in Review
Overall this feels like one of the weaker years for anime in recent memory. Yes, I’m giving 3 “outstanding” ratings, but 2 of them are for series begun…
GeGeGe no Kitaro, Golden Kamuy, Karakuri Circus, March Comes in Like a Lion, My Hero Academia
2022 Gunpla Year in Review
It gets quicker to make this list every year, and that’s not necessarily a good thing. In 2022, by my count, we got 30 new Gunpla this year.…
2021 Gunpla Year in Review
This is our second Gunpla Year in Review that has taken place during a global pandemic—not a milestone I ever wanted us to reach! However, it’s been interesting…
2021 Anime Year in Review
Hi everyone I’ve returned with my regular yearly round-up! For those who are new every year, I go through all the anime and manga I consumed and discuss…
2017 Anime Year in Review
2017 was like most years in anime: a lot of crap, some amusing but forgettable shows, some pretty good shows and a small number that seem like real…
Gabriel DropOut, Hozuki's Coolheadedness, Little Witch Academia, My Hero Academia, Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinju
The Top-Selling Manga In 2023 Are…
A little late to this one. Just had some things going on in my life.
I Predicted Every Game of the Year Nomination In 2023
I know. I’m awesome.
Critic’s Report: Asu no Yoichi!
This anime is awarded: Before watching this anime I thought to myself, “This is probably one of those harems ecchi shows where a lot of girls fall for…
Critic’s Report: Aoi Bunkagaku Series
This anime is awarded: One thing I have learned after finishing this series, that the world and its society is a one cruel place full with violence, madness,…
Critic’s Report: Asatte no Houkou
This anime is awarded: Karada is a young girl who hates being treated like a child and who wishes to be grown up. Shoko is an aloof, unhappy…
2023 in Review
A year of retreads and repeats, none of them good: War in Ukraine. War in the Middle East. Covid, flu, and RSV. Donald Trump and Joe Biden r...
Laughing Salesman, Noel's Fantastic Trip, Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End, Tomo-chan Is a Girl!, Undead Murder Farce
~SPOILER FREE~ SUMMARIZING THE YEAR! 2023
What a busy year 2023 was! I made a game, I made a big ol’ video essay, and I drew far too much. Played some games too, none…
My Clueless First Friend, Magical Destroyers, The Café Terrace and Its Goddesses, Tengoku Daimakyo, BanG Dream!
Happy 2023 - Year of the Rabbit!
Happy New Year! I've been too busy to make a New Year's image, so please enjoy this Urusei Yatsura one from the new series' official Twit...
Manga I Enjoyed in 2023
It's been another great year for manga. And I don't think we wouldn't have it any other way, right? I got to read a bunch of manga, old and…
The Backlog, Year 4: A Quarantine in Review
This one is about the incredibly long year of 2020-2021.