More often than not, critics take the hot seat when reviewing a work subject to the ire of its fandom when it does not align with their views. This week, our resident reviewers Chris and Lucas weigh in on what it means to approach anime works critically as reviewers.
Mar 21, 2024 • Subscribe
More like this
This Week in Anime - When East Meets West: Can We Call This 'Anime'?
The age-old debate over whether certain animation is "anime" continues. Join Chris and Nicky this week as they navigate this ongoing discourse, exploring the evolving world of animation…
When anime meets litterature
Just so you know, the idea from this post comes from the book Ikebukuro West Gate Park because, as normal it is that the first 2 volumes…
Blue Exorcist, Genji, Ikebukuro West Gate Park, Black Butler, Durarara!!
Anime Rule 34: Where Creativity Meets Anime Fandom
Explore the world of Anime Rule 34, a mix of creativity and fandom, giving rise to unique art forms beyond the anime realm.
This Week in Anime - When Does an Anime Need a Reboot?
Steve and Chris consider the necessity of rebooting popular anime like One Piece and Hunter x Hunter in the larger anime media landscape. Strap in, they talk about…
This Week in Anime - When Your Fav Anime Protagonist is Problematic
Heroes who do bad things aren't new to anime, but when is a protagonist flawed and complex and when are they an irredeemable scumbag?
When Fandom Becomes Work
Fandom is, first and foremost, about having fun…but lately, when I get home from work, I can’t summon the brain power to pay attention to anything longer than…
This Week in Anime - When in Rome, Bathe as the Romans Do
Thermae Romae Novae looks to reinvigorate Mari Yamazaki's historical comedy manga about bath culture with a brand new series on Netflix. Does this version manage to bring the…
This Week in Anime - What Happens When Magical Girls Grow Up?
Nicky and Chris, inspired by the recent raunchy Gushing Over Magical Girls, look at other more mature iterations of the magical girl genre.
This is fandom reporting in 2020
Recently a brand I mentioned in an article praised my coverage and asked if they could send me some of their products as a thank you. I replied…
Let’s Go! Anime Criticism in 2021
A few days ago I wrote up a thread on anime criticism I enjoyed reading/watching in 2021. I didn’t want it to be lost to the winds of…
[#Controversed] Week 4: Managing Criticism
If you have been following the Controversed project since the start of the month, thank you (!!), and congratulations for making it to the final week! For those…
This Week in Anime - Fan Anime
The new Berserk animation has been disavowed, but is this the only case of publishers coming down hard on fan creations? Steve and Chris dive into the world…
This Week in Anime - When A New Studio Takes Over Your Favorite Series
Steve and Chris compare some of the highs and lows of an anime studio change-up, from Attack on Titan and One-Punch Man to Spice and Wolf.
Life in an Anime Fandom
This was originally a response to Scott, but I ended up weaving my own post about a topic I wanted to write about anyway, so…here we are.
This Week in Anime - Which Anime Witch Is This?
Chris and Steve put on their pointy hats and hop on their brooms to magic up some witchy anime.
Summer 2024 Anime Week 2: This Week in Anime!
July 13th, 2024 We are well into the Summer season! Now that I’ve seen at least the first episode of most of the shows from this season, I…
This Week in Anime - Halloween Anime Spooktacular
Happy Halloween, anime fans! We have a special TWIA on this extra spooky Tuesday. Nick and Nicky discuss their favorite horror series and compare notes on which anime…
This Week in Anime - Anime Strike Out
Chris and Coop discuss the patchy history of anime on Amazon.
This Week in Anime - Shigeru Mizuki
Halloween may have passed but that won't stop Nicky and Steve from taking a deep dive into the OG of horror manga, Shigeru Mizuki.
This Week in Anime - Sophmore Slump
Coop and Chris try to answer the eternal question: does it matter if the sequel is as good if it takes too long to show up?
This Week in Anime - Shelf Life
Collecting anime on disc has Coop and Chris beside themshelves.
This Week in Anime - Looking Back
Steve and Lucas discuss creator Tatsuki Fujimoto and director Kiyotaka Oshiyama's Look Back film in all of its heartbreaking glory.
This Week in Anime - Utena's Revolution
Coop and Steve experience the ultimate destiny apocalypse with Revolutionary Girl Utena.
This Week in Anime - Conventional Gatherings
Chris and Lucas talk anime conventions, and why a smaller one focused on one IP can be a very different (and delightful) experience.
This Week in Anime - Disc World
Coop and Lucas discuss the importance of physical media. Bonus: libraries may soon be able to stock Kpop Demon Hunters on disc!
When Japan cool meets American violence
The bizarre confluence of a Japanese toymaker and an online agent of chaos.
When pop culture meets culture war
Dragon Quest III HD-2D and the pitfalls of producing content in a polarized world
This Week in Anime - When a Wife Guy Is Banished From the Hero's Party
Banished from the Hero's Party offers an appealing romance between a wife guy and a former adventurer princess... and then there's everything else.
This Week in Anime - Sex in Anime is Complicated
Nick and Lucas use last week's Chainsaw Man manga chapter as a springboard to discuss sex and sexuality in manga, from messy to raunchy to endearing depictions.
This Week in Anime - Snuggling in with Cozy Anime
Chris and Coop discuss their comfort watches for those days when you just want your anime to be the equivalent of a mug of hot cocoa.
Let’s Go! Anime Criticism in 2022 Part 2
We’re back! A few weeks ago, I did a thread on Twitter of some pieces about anime and manga I liked from last year. Since Twitter is on…
Let’s Go! Anime Criticism in 2022 Part 1
Once again, I’m summing up a thread I wrote on recent pop culture criticism on anime and manga I’ve enjoyed recently! This is part one, covering January to…
This Week in Anime - Reincarnated in Another Column
Another season, another glut of isekai. Chris and Lucas do their best to tackle the unending pile.
This Week in Anime - (Shonen) Jump Right In
Coop and Lucas browse the Shonen Jump app to sort out the good, the bad, and the Fujimoto-flavored.
This Week in Anime - Getter in that Robo!
Old school mecha fan Jean-Karlo introduces Steve to the world of Getter Robo Arc, subterrainian dinos, insect troops, and how it's all one big metaphor for nuclear power.
This Week in Anime - Love in Another World
Steve and Lucas pull double-duty as they tackle both the new season's isekai and rom-com anime.
This Week in Anime - The Boys in Toyland
Coop and Chris explore the world of marketable plastic goodies and how anime can turn out to be a half-hour toy commercial.
This Week in Anime - The Anime Movie Magic
Lucas and Steve discuss the new and old trends of anime in movie theaters.
This Week in Anime - Anime Ads and Commercials
From classic Toonami ads to the Catholic Church, Lucas and Steve take a look at the relationship between anime and advertisements over the years.
This Week in Anime - Caught Up in this Season's Whirlwind of Romance Anime
This week, Lucas and Nick sit down to talk about the surprisingly vast number of romance anime this season—and struggle to decide which are actually worth watching.
This Week in Anime - Are This Season's Isekai Anime Any Good?
Lucas gets his first taste of the TWIA's seasonal isekai sampler. Is there any spice this season, or is it all the same comfort food?
This Week in Anime - Libraries are Fun!
Coop and Steve discover the wonderful world of libraries and all of the anime and manga goodness they give you access to.
This Week in Anime - Stop-Motion Sensation
Coop and Steve explore the sometimes cute, sometimes creepy world of stop-motion animation.
This Week in Anime - The Movie Game
Chris and Steve dig into the venerable institution that is game-based movies and anime and the relationship between anime and video games.
This Week in Anime - Going Down Stream
Coop and Steve ponder the streaming landscape and how ridiculously impossible they've made it to get a decent screencap.
This Week in Anime - Girls Band Drama
Chris and Steve plumb the depths of the girl band genre and wonder how things got so dark.
This Week in Anime - Crunch(y) Time
Lucas and Steve reminisce about Crunchyroll Originals and ponder what the future holds for them under their shiny new name.
This Week in Anime - Gacha Money Now
Don't you hate it when your favorite mobile game goes kaput? Chris and Steve look at the current gacha game landscape, its questionable game mechanics, and the bitter…
This Week in Anime - Frieren's Demon Problem
Steve and Nick tune back in to Frieren: Beyond Journey's End to discuss the series' primary antagonists: demons and how fantasy often handles "evil races."
This Week in Anime - Get G-Recked
Gundam Reconguista in G, or G-Reco, sees the mega-franchise's founder Yoshiyuki Tomino return to the director's seat and boy is that a loaded statement. Jean-Karlo and Nicholas attempt…