Not Your Idol tries to examine some serious issues but lacks the delicacy to properly pull it off. I can see some readers enjoying it though.
May 21, 2021 • Subscribe
More like this
Ossan Idol! – Manga First Impression
Ossan Idol was far from perfect but it did get a few things right. Namely not taking itself too seriously or too lightly,
Not Your Idol, Vol. 1
By Aoi Makino. Released in Japan as “Sayonara Miniskirt” by Shueisha, serialization ongoing in the magazine Ribon. Released in North America by Viz Media. Translated by Tetsuichiro Miyaki.…
Not Your Idol Volume 2 Review
Not Your Idol's debut was a thoughtful look on the societal pressures women have to live with. Volume 2, however, feels much more muddled.
Preview Guide 4: Not Your Idol
This is a review of Not Your Idol volume 1, a new series by Aoi Makino that's going to be released by Viz.Not Your Idol tackles the ups…
First Impression: Phantom of the Idol
As one-half of the idol group ZINGS, Niyodo must put in the practice, effort, and love that will please the duo’s fans and lead them to popularity. Unfortunately,…
First Impression: To Your Eternity
Ok, it’s my fault. I knew what I was getting into. I’ve read the manga for To Your Eternity (by the same author as A Silent Voice) almost…
Zombieland Saga is not your typical idol anime
After watching something serious (B the Beginning) and romantic (Kiss Him, Not Me), I tried to watching something fun. As … More Zombieland Saga is not your typical…
Double – Manga First Impression
Acting manga are rare enough and even when we get one, it's about an unstoppable genius or a beautiful young ingenue. The Double manga is about an normal…
Mashle – Manga First Impression
I love a good comedy manga and Mashle may just be what I have been looking for.
Orient – Manga First Impression
Orient is a manga that is more impressive in potential than in execution. At least for volume 1. Here's why I thought that.
Nyankees – Manga First Impression
I bought Nyankees on a complete whim and I was surprised by what I got. You'll have to read the post to find out what that was!
Gigant – Manga First Impression
Have you ever wanted your classic science fiction manga to include a lot more sex? When I put it that way who wouldn't? Gigant has you covered
Manga First Impression: Moriking
Moriking is a new manga series from Shonen Jump by Tomohiro Hasegawa. The first chapter introduces elementary school student Shota Aikawa and his high school-aged sister sister, Shoko.…
Hirayasumi – Manga First Impression
I am holding my breath until Hirayasumi gets officially licensed in English. So you better get on it. Here I go, holding breath now!
Nyankees – Manga First Impression
I bought Nyankees on a complete whim and I was surprised by what I got. You'll have to read the post to find out what that was!
First Impression: To Your Eternity S2
For forty years, Fushi has stranded himself on an island where his isolation is interrupted only by the occasional appearance of the Beholder, who warns him of coming…
Dear Noman – Manga First Impression
I think it’s time I changed my opening paragraph for these as I’ve …
No. 5 – Manga First Impression
The No. 5 manga is challenging. Both to read and to review. In this post, I try my best to share my experience with it.
Manga First Impression: Sakamoto Days
The first chapter of the new series Sakamoto Days dropped on Shonen Jump today. Sakamoto Days is a tale as old as time—man becomes incredibly effective assassin; man…
Manga First Impression: Bone Collection
Jun Kirarazaka’s new manga, Bone Collection, is set in a world where yokai are always on the prowl and often attacking humans. Into this world steps Kazami, a…
Manga First Impression: Blue Box
Blue Box is the newest manga series to hit Shonen Jump. From mangaka Kouji Miura, who previously created two different shonen romance series, this one seems to fall…
ZOM 100 – Manga First Impression
Have you ever read a manga that made you redefine yourself? ZOM 100 did that for me. I am now a fan of zombie comedies. Wild!
Dai Dark – Manga First Impression
Dai Dark is the latest manga from the author of Dorohedoro. And as you can imagine, it's fairly unique. Let me tell you what I thought.
Eniale & Dewiela – Manga First Impression
Eniale & Dewiela is a fun if flawed new manga. Here are my thoughts after volume 1.
Mieruko-Chan – Manga First Impression
In my continuing search for my next great manga love, I take a look at the first volume of supernatural comedy: Mieruko-chan.
Penguin & House – Manga First Impression
I'm a sucker for a cute pet so Penguin & House seemed right up my alley. But I found there were some things lacking.
First Impression: Undead Unluck (Manga)
This past weekend a new manga series from Yoshifumi Tozuka dropped on Shonen Jump entitled Undead Unluck. The first chapter has…a lot. The chapter begins with Fuuko Izumo…
Manga First Impression: Candy Flurry
Candy Flurry is the newest manga series from Shonen Jump. With art by Mitarashi Santa and written by Takegushi Ippon, the series features a very different and interesting…
Inside Mari – Manga First Impression
Inside Mari is the latest manga by Shuzo Oshimi author of Flowers of Evil and Happiness. An intriguing body swap story with a strong start.
ZOM 100 – Manga First Impression
Have you ever read a manga that made you redefine yourself? ZOM 100 did that for me. I am now a fan of zombie comedies. Wild!
Blank Canvas – Manga First Impression
Twitter told me to pick up Blank Canvas so now I have a bone to pick.
Manga First Impression – Blue Period
Bleu Period is an interesting manga with a lot to offer, but it also follows a lot of classical tropes and structures.
Manga First Impression – Hell’s Paradise
Well this was an experience. A really bloody one. Hell's Paradise mixes supernatural elements with good old fashion hack and slash.
Manga First Impression: Ayakashi Triangle
Ayakashi Triangle is a new Shonen Jump manga series from Kentaro Yabuki, who is best known for Black Cat and serving as the artist for To Love Ru.…
Suiyou Kyoudai – Manga First Impression
I came across Suiyou Kyoudai completely by accident and feel in love. It's great when that happens! I think you could fall in love too.
Manga First Impression: Phantom Seer
Shonen Jump’s newest series is Phantom Seer. The artwork is done by Kento Matsuura, who does a fantastic job developing a new world setting. But what is kind…
Manga First Impression: Me & Roboco
The latest manga series from Shonen Jump is Me & Roboco (Boku to Roboco) by mangaka Shuhei Miyazaki, previouslyknown for the 4-koma The Promised Neverland spinoff, Oyakusoku no…
First Impression: Shikimori’s Not Just a Cutie
Second-year high school student Izumi sets off on the first day of the new school year. His mom’s warning as he leaves sounds like a joke…until we learn…
First Impression: Love Live! Nijigasaki High School Idol Club
Yuu and Ayumu are longtime best friends who were just hanging out one day when they stumbled across a solo idol performance. The performance lit a fire in…
The Anti-Social Geniuses Review: Not Your Idol Volume 1
The Anti-Social Geniuses review Volume 1 of Aoi Makino's Not Your Idol, where a former idol tries to overcome her assault by acting like a boy.
First Impression: ONIMAI: I’m Now Your Sister!
Mahiro Oyama is your typical unemployed young man still living in his parents’ house, until one day when he wakes up and finds he’s been turned into a…
First Impression: Keep Your Hands off Eizouken!
Asakusa is a high school freshman eager to join her school anime’s club. Dragging along her curt, avaricious friend, Kanamori, she goes to the club’s opening day screening,…
Manga First Impression: Time Paradox Ghostwriter
Time Paradox Ghostwriter is a new manga series from author Kenji Ichima and artist Tsunehiro Date that began this week in Shonen Jump. The premise is super simple:…
Superwomen in Love – Manga First Impression
Are you looking for a new Yuri series to enjoy? How about Superwomen in Love. It might be just the things and I'll tell you why.
Love and Heart – Manga First Impression
Love and Heart is an unusual manga in that it's a genre that isn't often explored in manga. It has quite a few flaws but I found it…
Manga First Impression: The Elusive Samurai
The Elusive Samurai is the newest series by Yusei Matsui, creator of Assassination Classroom. Instead of a science fiction series set at a school, The Elusive Samurai is…
Manga First Impression – The Apothecary Diaries
The-Apothecary-Diaries is an interesting mix of classical medical drama, mystery and romance in the imperial palace.
Manga First Impression: Ghost Reaper Girl
Weekly Shonen Jump’s newest series is Ghost Reaper Girl, a manga from Akihisa Ikeda ,the creator Rosario+Vampire. Interestingly, Ikeda has specifically requested that western releases of Ghost Reaper…
Manga First Impression – After Work Duet
You guys know my habits by now. The Japanese title reminded me so much of film, Shall We Dance?, and having the focus being on older non-professional dancers…
Manga First Impression: i tell c
i tell c is a new manga series from Kazusa Inaoka. The header of this Shonen Jump series says that it’s a “…unique take on the crime-suspense genre,” and…