Don't get me wrong. Carole and Tuesday is not a bad show- the animation is good, and I really like the world building of its futuristic setting. The music, though predominantly pop which isn't really to my taste, is pretty alright. But I think the biggest issue the show has is that it's too ambitious. It has too many ideas that it tries to explore, but lacks a single focus which it can explore in sufficient depth.The first half of the show feels like it should be some kind of exploration into AI music versus human music. We see Angela being aided by Mr. Tao's AI machinery in order to create the ideal song for her, even later being able to create some sort vocaloid of her which can replicate her singing perfectly. This is juxtaposed with Carole and Tuesday, who write their own song lyrics and make their own tunes. The question posed within the rivalry between Angela and C&T is can AI music, or more broadly speaking any artistic work created by a machine, be the same or better than what is created by a human? Unfortunately, this question is just not answered. Carole and Tuesday do not win the Mars' Brightest competition to triumph over Angela's AI music. And quite frankly, the show makes it hard to differentiate between music made by AI and what is written by humans, it kinda just sounds the same as regular music.The second half of the show is definitely some kind of allusion towards the current immigration issue in America. Valery is anime Donald Trump with her anti immigrant stance and even before she's elected we see immigrants get arrested and deported by the police. This political subplot honestly didn't have a good resolution. The whole immigration issue is resolved too easily. Valery drops out of her campaign once she finds out Jerry is responsible for the bombing. I had imagined that Carole and Tuesday's final song would be responsible for Valery's change in heart (as cheesy as that would be)- that is why that song is stressed as miraculous at the start of every episode.Make Mars great again!Aside from the poorly done political subplot, the second half tries to focus on the power of music to expose societal issues and enact change- for example we see Ezekiel's "Crash the Server" rebel against censorship and "Mother" is basically the uniting "We are the World" of this anime. I do like the heart behind these songs, but I'd like to see their effects more greatly explored. For example, we don't get to see how "Mother", a song intended to bring people together, calms down the anti-immigrant hysteria on Mars.Aside from those, there are many other concepts that seem to have not bore much fruit. We see the struggles with depression and addiction that are not unfamiliar to musicians, such as in Flora's backstory or in Angela coping with the death of her mother. Angela literally collapses on stage and when Mr. Tao shows up she's fine and done with taking drugs. We see the dangerous side of having a big following, reflected in Tuesday and Angela's stalkers... though after their ordeals nothing changes in the show and life carries on. Also there's thing about the radiation on mars turning people into hermaphrodites which is never really touched on, honestly seeming more like an excuse to just have a bunch of sex ambiguous characters on screen. If you're gonna have it, you could at least go more in depth with it. How are these individuals viewed by society? Are these individuals comfortable the way they are? It's not really needed if you don't go into it.It's a shame. Carole and Tuesday is really fortunate to have 24 episodes, yet their time is squandered. This is the first anime I think could've done with a shorter runtime. A more focused 12 episodes over a loose 24. Part of the issue is due to director Shinichiro Watanabe's style of making episodic stories rather than having an overarching one, resulting in different episodes/arcs exploring different ideas. But even so his greatest work, Cowboy Bebop, manages to have an episodic structure yet maintain a consistent theme. Carole and Tuesday could've been so much better if it could just find something and stick to it.
Oct 5, 2019 • Subscribe
More like this
THOUGHTS ON: CAROLE & TUESDAY
Carole & Tuesday is a show that is crippled by its own potential. It has such a strong ambition—one unreasonable for any TV broadcast to meet—and that is…
OtakuGeneration.net :: (Show #751) Carole and Tuesday
Shownotes :: (show 751) :: (website) :: (podcast feed) :: (direct download) :: (direct iTunes link) With Carole and Tuesday, recorded live October 27th, 2019. This week,…
Carole and Tuesday Episode 24 Review
Welcome all she’s he’s and them’s to a much-belated post about Carole and Tuesday. Due to a long hiatus, I’m way behind on seasonal anime. But better late…
Carole & Tuesday Episode 5
Episode 5 “Every Breath You Take” [from the same name as The Police song] Production Details Episode Director: Noriyuki Nomata [ Animation Unit Director on Danganronpa The…
Carole & Tuesday Episode 4
Episode 4 “Video Killed the Radio Star” [from the same name as the Buggles song] Production Details Episode Director: Tsuyoshi Tobita [Episode Director on A.I.C.O. -Incarnation- Episodes…
Carole & Tuesday Episode 3
Episode 3 “Fire and Rain” [from the same name as the James Taylor song] Production Details Episode Director: Satoshi Takafuji [Episode Director on Kiznaiver Episode 10 / Episode Director…
Carole & Tuesday Episode 7
Episode 7 “Show me The Way” [from the same name as the Peter Frampton song] Production Details Episode Director: Satoshi Takato [Script on Gokyodai Monogatari film /…
Carole & Tuesday – First Impressions
There are only a few director/creators in anime that their mere name is enough to make a sizable portion of anime fandom commit to watching their shows. This…
Carole & Tuesday, Lupin III, Lupin the 3rd Part V, Space Dandy
Carole & Tuesday Episode 2
Episode 2 “Born to Run” [from the same name as the Bruce Springsteen song] Production Details Episode Director: Shōhei Miyake Script: Deko Akao Storyboard: Manabu Okamoto Chief Animatio…
Carole & Tuesday Episode 6
Episode 6 “Life is a Carnival” [from the same name as The Band song] Production Details Episode Director: Shohei Miyake [Episode Director on A.I.C.O. Incarnation ONA series Episodes…
The Power of Three: Carole and Tuesday
Elsewhere I’ve written about the way Shinichiro Watanabe treats female characters, which is to say for the most part much more fairly than most anime writers and directors.…
Carole and Tuesday: Express Yourself Through Music
Oh hey, everyone. How you’ve been? You ever have a larger amount of time that you spent just relaxing or only partially doing something and then finally come…
Together | Part 3: Carole & Tuesday
the space between us is who we are. A hot wind, a white sea, a film. The very last word in The White Girl’s closing monologue (see part…
[Review] Carole & Tuesday – Episode 1
What a lovely, lovely, lovely first episode. The post [Review] Carole & Tuesday – Episode 1 appeared first on ANIME FEMINIST.
Carole & Tuesday Episode 1 [Initial Impressions]
PLOT: Fifty years have passed since mankind began migrating to the new frontier: Mars. It’s an age where most culture is produced by AI, and…
Carole & Tuesday: A Musical Dialogue | Shinichiro Watanabe x Mocky
A roundtable published on ele-king on April 10, 2019, in commemoration of the first episode premiere of the TV anime Carole & Tuesday. Interview & Text: Takune Kobayashi…
[Nine] Round and round like dancing laundry — Carole & Tuesday
One of the most popular songs of my adolescence was The Backstreet Boys’ “I Want It That Way.” If you actually bother to listen to the lyrics of…
Carole & Tuesday director Hori Motonobu on the series’ writing process and trans characters
The series saw praise for its well-characterized Black heroine, optimistic outlook and its swing-for-the-fences tale of pushing back against injustice (including a spot in our 2019 recs list).…
Carole & Tuesday – Sonata in B-flat Major
Titles: Carole & Tuesday, C&T, Carole y Tuesday Genre: Drama, music, scifi Episodes: 24 Studio: BONES There’s something magical about music, isn’t there? And by extension about the…
Spiraken Anime Review Ep 09: Carole & Tuesday
In this music filled episode of the Spiraken Anime Review, Xan & Gretta review the latest anime series by acclaimed director Shinichiro Watanabe in collaboration with Studio Bones.…
Portrayals of Black Masculinity in Carole & Tuesday
Despite its social justice-minded storytelling, Carole & Tuesday can be a frustrating watch as it swings back and forth between exploring these characters as nuanced individuals and perpetuating…
Carole & Tuesday by Watanabe Shinichiro / Yamataka Morito
I picked up the first two volumes of the rock-and-roll futuristic fantasy, Carole & Tuesday at my library. You’ll have to do the same, if you’re interested, because…
5 Reasons Why You Should Watch Carole & Tuesday
Have you ever wondered why Carole & Tuesday gained a number of fans? It’s an anime that looks plain and dry at first glance, but in reality, it’s…
What I’m Watching – Carole & Tuesday (Eps. 1-12)
Note: This post contains some spoilers for the series through episode 12. This past weekend I got the opportunity to speak at GalaxyCon, a multi-media fandom convention in…
The Speakeasy #114: Carole and Tuesday, Thunderbolt Fantasy Movie 2, Beastars
We do a spoiler-free review of Carole & Tuesday, discuss the ridiculousness of Thunderbolt Fantasy: Betwitching Melody of the West, and do a spoiler-y analysis of Beastars S1.…
Psycho Pass, Carole and Tuesday, and more why anime features anti-immigration elections
I’ve been catching up with season 3 of Psycho Pass lately. I’m up to episode 4 of 8 and, despite some initial skepticism with the rather poorly explained…
NDK 2022 a Critique
A special presentation brought to you by Tim and Weltall. We talk about the bad at Nan Desu Kan 2022. Not because we hate it, but because we…
Discordant Tones: Oversimplifying music as resistance in Carole & Tuesday
Carole and Tuesday are just two girls dreaming of becoming musicians. While the series initially follows the girls' rise to stardom, the focuses shifts to examine how…
TangleCast 75: Interview with Nai Br.XX of Carole & Tuesday
Hey quarantined crew, we’ve got a special episode of the TangleCast for you this week! Musician Nai Br.XX, the singing voice for Carole in the Carole & Tuesday…
12 Days Of Christmas Anime, Day 6: Carole & Tuesday, A Melody Of Hope
One of my favorite traditions this time of the year is Christmas music. I have my own Spotify playlist that I’ve updated over the years, adding more songs…
Anime Impressions: Carole & Tuesday Review (Ep. 1-24 English Dub)
WARNING: SPOILERS!I should warn the prospective reader that there’s definitely SPOILERs here! I consider myself spoiler proof. After all, if it’s ruined just by someone telling you what…
[Links] 28 August – 3 September 2019: Podcast Retrospectives, Carole and Tuesday, and Miku Created Minecraft
AniFem Round-Up [Perspectives] Our Dreams at Dusk and the Process of Healing Through Found Families Dani M celebrates Yuhki Kamatani’s latest series and its skill in depicting queer…
Reader’s Corner: Carole and Tuesday, SW Guardians of the Whills, and Laid-back Camp, Vol. 10
Laid-back Camp, Vol. 10 With the recent season long gone and months since volume nine was released, I’ve been suffering from Yuru Camp withdrawal. There’s nothing out there…
Pokemon Presents on Tuesday!
Theres gonna be a Pokemon Presents on Tuesday thats gonna be half an hour long! I wonder what itll announce? I really hope itll be something good.
A Brutally Honest Elden Ring Critique
Elden Ring is one of the biggest and most influential games that's come out in a long time. And while every Elden Ring review seems to be a…
How I Rank and Critique Manga
Clueless Best Friend 🙃 Thought I’d give a brief explanation of what my ratings for manga are and an update on some future content.
The Best of Us, The Worst of Us, the Lot of Us: Carole and Tuesday
These two soul sisters represent much more than just music.
Insufficient Direction and Sweet Blue Flowers
Episode lucky number seven, unlike the movie Lucky Number Slevin, which is an alright movie and has...
Insufficient Direction and Sweet Blue Flowers
Episode lucky number seven, unlike the movie Lucky Number Slevin, which is an alright movie and has Lucy Liu, but anyway. The Dodgers and Astros are in the…
Reader’s Corner: Carole & Tuesday, Rascal Does Not Dream of Siscon Idol, and The Rampage of Haruhi Suzumiya
Rascal Does Not Dream of Siscon Idol (Rascal, Vol. 4) My most consistent complaint about the Rascal series, which I otherwise find charming, is that the stories are…
Animated Observations Update #8: "Its Been a While" and Going on Break
Cmon, don’t look at me like that, life is hard, okay. But, seriously, I apologize for the lack of serious updates outside of random tweets in the last…
A Disappointing Anime Season And Its Savior
The disappointing 2022 Summer Anime season, from worst to best. Support me: https://www.patreon.com/spirit_chaser Donate: https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/Contreras2992 My Anime List: https://myanimelist.net/profile/Spirit_Chaser Anilist: https://anilist.co/user/SpiritChaser RWBY: Ice Queendom - Intro Call of the Night - 00:01:56 Orient Part 2…
Call of the Night, I'M KODAMA KAWASHIRI, Lycoris Recoil, Made in Abyss, Summer Time Rendering
GameStop Chews On Its Future
With Chewy founder Ryan Cohen taking control of GameStop, what does this mean for the gaming store? Krystallina gives her thoughts.
Romantic Killer – The Overlooked Anime of 2022, and a Critique of Societal Expectations
Romantic Killer is a scathing critique of the notion that women cannot be self-reliant without the involvement of a man in their lives, while surprisingly also briefly touching…
A Growing Inertia: Patlabor 2’s Critique of Telecommunications
A deep dive into anime classic Patlabor 2, which explores the film's critiques of the growing influence of our increasingly connected world.
Anime Pulse 745: Ascendance of a Carole
This week on Anime Pulse, there’s a lot of things broken! We start off with side notes of health improvements and sudden home repair projects, before diving into…
Quick Update: Current Direction
Hi guys, Floating Sunfish here with a quick update on our current direction. With MangaDex currently being down for the time being, and with all upcoming chapters being…
Great Pretender (and its unfulfilled potential): A Review
Great Pretender is a fantastic production that is sadly overshadowed by an unengaging story
Tokiwasō and its neighborhood.
In the web supplement to Tokyo Stroll I have added a new page for the Tokiwasō Area . In the Anime Companion Supplement I have added…
D&D and its future, and my take on the whole saga
About Open Game License (OGL). If you are a regular D&D watcher / player, you would know by now about WotC (Wizard of the coast) and its proposed…